FREELANCE WRITER. JOURNALIST, AND SCRIPT READER – FAN OF SCI-FI AND CHOCOLATE DIGESTIVES – YSTV'S BEST DRESSED MEMBER 2013

Friday, 30 November 2018


One thing I’m enjoying about Series 11 is the variety of places on Earth we’re visiting. Russell T Davies’ Who was London-centric and Moffat tended towards geographical vagueness, but so far this year we’ve been to Sheffield, Alabama, the Punjab, and now Lancashire, with the specificity making each of these diverse settings feel more tangible. This is a particularly exciting one for me, because Pendle Hill isn’t far from where I grew up.

Based on this series’ sensitive treatment of history and culture so far, then, and given writer Joy Wilkinson is a Lancastrian too, they were inevitably going to treat my county with respect and not come up with a town name that sounds like a medieval sewage dump.

So the Doctor and friends land in Bilehurst Cragg... oh... ah, well... and soon find themselves embroiled in the Pendle witch trials. Adventure ensues.

My main impression of The Witchfinders is the same simple point that summed up Kerblam! – it begins with a concept that’s thoroughly well suited for Doctor Who and tells that story well. Every character has something to do, there’s clear plotting, a clear theme (the witchfinders as bullies of women) and a clear tone (Hammer-esque camp, spooky horror). All this allows it to flow in a pleasant way that makes for one of the most rewatchable episodes of the series. This level of basic competence perhaps shouldn’t be remarkable, but given four out of the first five episodes of this series were irritatingly messy, it does feel remarkable how much it’s raised its game since Chris Chibnall passed the baton to his team of guest writers.


A few aspects elevate the episode above basic competency, though, and the first is the most brilliant piece of Doctor Who guest casting since Kylie Minogue played a waitress on the Titanic. The role of King James I (VI to the Scots) must have looked odd on the page, not particularly necessary to the plot and with some rather dramatic dialogue that could easily make for the most cringeworthy guest character since James Corden played the Doctor's mate James Corden.  But the invincible Boris from GoldenEye more than pulls it off, treating every scene with the same flamboyant sense of fun with which he pissed Chibnall off by being the only person to leak a single detail about this series’ plots. Every scene with him is brilliant, right down to the way he camply flaps his cape when sitting down in a huff. I’m no monarchist, but King James is now a queer icon. 

The other major strength of The Witchfinders is its treatment of gender. No episodes so far have really shown Jodie Whittaker’s Doctor being treated differently because she’s now a woman, which may have been wise to start with so as to let her cement herself in any doubters’ minds that she is the same Doctor we’ve known for twelve previous incarnations. But the show had to address this issue at some point or another, and there may not be a more appropriate story with which to do so than this one: it’s about a historical atrocity committed specifically against women, which was long enough ago that the Doctor almost becoming a victim of it can be treated with some levity rather than feeling distasteful, but which allows for some nevertheless relevant dialogue about misogyny. James’s patronising attitude towards the Doctor and declaration that “the general can’t be a woman” before being proved otherwise seems to me a metatextual comment on the backlash to Whittaker’s casting, another aspect of this episode that could have been clunky as hell but is judged with enough subtlety and sits right within the episode’s wider themes. 

It definitely helps that The Witchfinders has a female writer. Indeed, letting a Lancastrian woman do an episode about the Pendle witch trials shows off a major strength of Series 11 – guest writers have been given lease to write stories reflective of their own experiences and culture, with the consequence that Rosa, Demons of the Punjab and this have all felt like they have something to say, in a way that individual episodes of Moffat’s Who much less frequently did. It makes me excited to see whether the same team will stick around for the next series or whether Chibnall will bring on even more diverse recruits.


Female director, too, for those of you counting, and I like what Sallie Aprahamian did here. The finale could have been bland and exposition-heavy, but feels like a proper Hammer movie showdown, visually punchy, while the desaturated brown and green colour palette makes for a nice rural horror atmosphere. Every episode this year has had a distinct and cinematic look, another strength of Series 11; the bit of Wales that played a Lancashire forest this week probably isn’t far from the bit of Wales that played India two weeks ago, but through considered grading and sound design, they’ve both felt like Lancashire and India respectively.

That said, does the Doctor’s trial scene feel oddly put together to anyone else? The reliance on close-ups means that the companions and James have to stay on the same spot, which is weirdly static, and that the geography is unclear. And if you don’t see what I mean by that, try drawing a map of where all the action in that scene takes place. I bet you struggle.

But anyway, another very strong episode all around. And let’s not forget Graham in the big hat. Laughed every time I saw it.

DOCTOR WHO SERIES 11 RANKING

  1. Rosa
  2. Kerblam!
  3. Demons of the Punjab
  4. The Witchfinders
  5. Arachnids in the UK
  6. The Tsuranga Conundrum
  7. The Woman Who Fell to Earth
  8. The Ghost Monument
(Though I'm starting to wish I could be bothered to work out how to make the list say Kerblam!, Demons, and Witchfinders are all joint second. They're very close.)

12 comments:

  1. Happy To Read All your Page Content God Bless you And do visit our Page For More Information Vidmate Keep Sharing

    ReplyDelete
  2. You're really something special. vidmate and You're so thoughtful Looking For More Posts

    ReplyDelete
  3. I am really thankful to read your content. andClash Of Clans MOD APK thank you for sharing with us.

    ReplyDelete
  4. https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/canelo-alvarez-vs-jacobs-event-time/
    Canelo Alvarez vs Jacobs Event Time That's where using a VPN comes in.Short for Virtual Private Networking, it's an ideal piece of software that allows you to change your IP address so you appear to be in a completely different location. (i.e. one that's actually showing the boxing).They're are also really handy if you're concerned about streaming safely on the web, thanks to the encryption they use to hide your details. Canelo Alvarez vs Jacobs Event Time And the best won't log your personal information, either. Big-time boxing season is here. Over the next few weeks, the top three heavyweights in the world -- Anthony Joshua, Deontay Wilder and Tyson Fury -- and top middleweights Canelo Alvarez and Gennady Golovkin are each headlining major events in New York City or Las Vegas.

    ReplyDelete
  5. https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/jacobs-vs-alvarez-boxing-buy-las-vegas-tickets/
    Jacobs vs Alvarez Boxing Buy Las Vegas Tickets

    Saul 'Canelo' Alvarez will defend his WBA and WBC middleweight titles against IBF champion Daniel Jacobs in title unification fight in Las Vegas. Canelo returns to the middleweight division to cement his dominance after fighting in another division against Rocky Fielding to obtain the WBA super middleweight title. The American boxer won the vacant IBF middleweight title stripped from Gennady Golovkin after winning by split decision against Sergiy Derevyanchenko last year. Sportsmail will provide you all you need to know for Jacobs vs Alvarez Boxing Buy Las Vegas Tickets including time, date and location plus how to watch, ticket prices and latest odds. According to boxing records website Boxrec , Ryder made his professional debut against Ben Deghani in 2010. Ryder is currently on a three-fight win streak going back to October 2017.

    ReplyDelete
  6. https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/when-is-canelo-alvarezs-next-fight-date-time-price/
    When Is Canelo Alvarez's Next Fight Date Time Price

    Boxing fans wanted Crawford to face IBF titlist Errol Spence Jr. tosee who the king of the division and the sport would be. Spence fought Mikey Garcia in March instead, so Crawford went to one of the biggest names in the game. Khan won the 140-pound WBA title from Andreas Kotelnik in July 2009. The 32-year-old made four straight defenses of the belt before adding the IBF strap in when he scored a fifth-round knockout of Zab Judah in July 2011. The sentiment is that Jacob, 32, will be one of the stiffest tests of When Is Canelo Alvarez's Next Fight Date Time Price which is saying something, considering the Mexican star has been inside the ring two times with Golovkin and Mayweather. Boxing pundits and fans alike feel Khan has seen his better days, and Crawford will make it look rather easy. Khan possesses the experience and packs a hard enough punch to where he can give Crawford plenty of problems.

    ReplyDelete
  7. https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/how-to-watch-canelo-alvarez-vsdaniel-jacobs-live-online/
    How To Watch Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs Live Online

    The card starts at 8 p.m. ET. It won’t be televised on regular cable in the United States, but you can watch a live stream of both semifinal fights on DAZN. DAZN, which also has exclusive broadcasting rights in the US for the fights of Canelo Alvarez next weekend, May 4 vs Daniel Jacobs, How To Watch Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs Live Online Anthony and Gennady Golovkin costs either $19.99 per month or $99.99 for a year, which comes out to just over $8 per month. Jacobs, 31, is a native of Brooklyn, New York who is widely considered as one of the best middleweights of this era. Jacobs rose up the middleweight rankings to win the WBA Middleweight World Title against Jarrod Fletcher in 2014 after being away from the sport for 19 months, due to a form of bone cancer that he courageously overcame. Jacobs made several successful defenses, including a thunderous first-round knockout of Peter Quillin the following year.

    ReplyDelete
  8. https://canelovsjacobsfights.com/canelo-alvarez-vs-daniel-jacobs-predictions-odds-preview/
    Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs Predictions Odds Preview

    Canelo Alvarez is set to face Daniel Jacobs on May 4 and the Mexican brawler is busy training for the said fight. However, that does not mean that the 28-year-old is not accommodating visitors. In fact, he welcomed Maverick Carter recently and got something from NBA star LeBron James. According to TMZ Sports, Carter took a trip to Alvarez’ training camp in San Diego and gave the Mexican some hot kicks. They were a pair of LeBron 16 “Martin” shoes, one of the most coveted shoes in the market. Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs Predictions Odds Preview was awed by the gift and told Carter to give James his thanks for the kicks. For those who may be unaware, James and Carter are producing a docuseries of the fight.

    ReplyDelete
  9. https://emmyawardsdaytime.com/will-the-daytime-emmy-awards-be-televised/
    Will The Daytime Emmy Awards Be Televised

    On September 18, 2018, Soaps.com first announced the air date for this year’s the 46thth Annual Daytime Emmys Awards, which will be held at the Pasadena Civic Auditorium at 300 E Green Street in Pasadena, California on Sunday May 5 to honor The Bold and the Beautiful, Days of our Lives, General Hospital and The Young and the Restless along with their actors. Following the big night where soap stars and other daytime personalities come together to celebrate excellence in American Will The Daytime Emmy Awards Be Televised television, winners will join hosts Sheryl Underwood, Sharon Osborne, Eve and Carrie Ann Inaba for The Talk’s After Party on Monday May 6 at 2:00 PM Eastern. Former host and creator Sara Gilbert announced on Tuesday April 9 that she would be leaving the talk show but would return for guest-hosting in the future.

    ReplyDelete
  10. https://emmyawardsdaytime.com/46th-daytime-emmy-awards-nommés-et-lauréats/
    46th Daytime Emmy Awards Nommés Et Lauréats

    The final round of voting will be underway, as the 2019 Daytime Emmy Awards nominations were announced back in March to include various soap opera actors hoping to take home an Emmy statuette. The live ceremony will not be televised but fans will be able to watch the 2019 Daytime Emmys live streamed online via social media platforms such 46th Daytime Emmy Awards Nommés Et Lauréats Facebook Live, Twitter and Instagram. Earlier, we reported that Extra’s Mario Lopez and The Talk’s Sheryl Underwood will host the 2019 Daytime Emmys ceremony. The Talk has won a few Daytime Emmys over the years since its debut on October 18, 2010 as part of CBS’ Daytime programming. The show is currently in its 9th season and discusses the latest headlines.

    ReplyDelete
  11. https://emmyawardsdaytime.com/46th-daytime-emmy-awards-nominados-y-ganadores/
    46th Daytime Emmy Awards Nominados Y Ganadores

    Be sure to make your Daytime Emmy predictions so that Hollywood insiders can see how their shows and performers are faring in our odds. You can keep changing your predictions until winners are announced on May 5. And join in the fierce debate over the 2019 Daytime Emmys taking place right now with Hollywood insiders in our daytime TV forums. Read more Gold Derby entertainment news. The 46th Daytime Emmy Awards Nominados Y Ganadores nominees include household names such as Ellen DeGeneres, Whoopi Goldberg, Kelly Ripa, Ryan Seacrest, and O's very own Gayle King. And while watching the show sounds like it'd be easy, things get somewhat tricky. The National Academy of Television Arts and Sciences (NATAS) also sub-divides the daytime ceremonies into regular and Creative Arts Awards. Confused yet? Don’t worry, we’ve got you covered. Here’s everything you need to know about the 46th annual Daytime Emmy Awards.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Good Job you Are sharing Such a effective and informative stuff
    clash of magic
    clash of magic Apk

    ReplyDelete